Navigating a Rally You Love to Hate: Lessons from a Trader’s Mindset

I want to address something crucial today: the market’s ability to continuously climb higher despite headlines screaming uncertainty—whether it's war, tariffs, or rate cut delays. Traders frequently fall into the trap of viewing markets in binary terms. We assume straightforward cause-and-effect: if economic data is strong, we predict fewer rate cuts and therefore bearish conditions. Conversely, weak data signals rate cuts and bullish moves. But this oversimplification can lead to missed opportunities and unnecessary losses.

Consider the recent nonfarm payrolls report. The market quickly revised expectations downward after ADP private payrolls came in far below forecasts. Traders adjusted their views based on one piece of data—one singular input. Yet when the official numbers were released, we found complexities many overlooked: the labor force shrank significantly, mainly due to fewer foreign-born workers. Companies, facing fewer available workers, have begun automating more aggressively, with Amazon notably expanding its robotic workforce.

From a purely economic perspective, fewer workers available can push wages higher and drive greater automation, both scenarios beneficial for corporate profitability. Remember, earnings remain the critical driver of stocks over the long term. Thus, despite immediate uncertainty or negative headlines, market fundamentals can often remain strong.

Now let's shift to another important topic: dealing emotionally and strategically with the rally many traders—including myself—partially missed. Recently, I was flat during a significant market decline and re-entered once indicators confirmed a reversal. Some would argue I "missed" substantial upside, but this perspective ignores the downside I successfully avoided.

In trading, perfection is an illusion. Very few buy at the exact lows or sell at the precise highs. My strategy involves disciplined decision-making, guided by clear signals such as weekly closes relative to the 200-period moving average and critical chart patterns like double tops. This discipline ensures consistency and longevity in the market, even if it means missing some of the extremes.

Finally, let's openly discuss losses—an inevitable part of trading. Recently, I was stopped out of a trade in Okta. Initially, the trade looked promising but failed to reach my target. Instead of adjusting my stops or averaging down—a mistake I've seen traders make too often—I respected my original strategy and exited promptly when my stop-loss was triggered.

There's a psychological freedom in accepting losses swiftly and completely. Once stopped out, I remove all markers of the trade from my charts, erasing the temptation to emotionally revisit the decision. Whether the price moves favorably afterward is irrelevant. What matters is that I followed my process correctly, protected capital, and positioned myself effectively for future trades.

Markets are never simple, and successful trading isn't binary. Embracing complexity, maintaining discipline in the face of emotional challenges, and accepting losses as part of the process are what set seasoned traders apart from the rest. Keep your focus on strategy and process, and let the market take care of the rest.

Risk management remains the cornerstone of any successful trading approach. I consistently apply a dynamic position-sizing method, adjusting risk based on my account's current value. If my account value drops due to losses, I scale down my position size accordingly. This process protects me by ensuring that losing streaks inflict progressively smaller financial damage.

For instance, if my account shrinks from $25,735 to $25,360 after a losing trade, I recalibrate my next trade's risk accordingly. Instead of risking the original amount, I adjust the trade size to reflect the smaller account balance. This strategy is crucial because wins and losses often come in clusters. By reducing risk during losing streaks, I maintain sustainability and emotional resilience, significantly lowering the chances of substantial account drawdowns.

This brings us to a critical point: debunking the harmful myth of averaging down. Throughout my trading career, especially during my years on the trading floor, I've repeatedly seen traders mistakenly add to losing positions, believing that averaging down would rescue them from losses. In reality, averaging down compounds risk and can rapidly lead to catastrophic losses.

On the trading floor, we referred to averaging down as "adding to a loser," and those who regularly did this rarely lasted. The smarter and safer approach is to protect your capital rigorously. When a trade moves against you and hits your predetermined stop-loss, exit immediately. Preserving capital allows you to continue trading and capture future opportunities instead of trying to salvage a failing trade.

Another pervasive myth is the idea that successful trading means consistently buying low and selling high. This phrase might sound appealing but rarely aligns with market reality. Stocks making new highs often continue climbing for sound fundamental reasons, while stocks hitting new lows frequently continue downward. Thus, buying high and selling even higher is often a more reliable strategy for capturing strong trends.

Live Sessions (hereafter referred to as the “Content”) are produced by TradeZero. The Content may include the views and opinions of TradeZero and a third-party participant, Bob Iaccino. Bob Iaccino is compensated by TradeZero for participating in the Content. Mr. Iaccino’s trading experiences and accomplishments are unique, and your trading results may vary substantially from his. TradeZero is not responsible for and neither affirms nor endorses any of Mr. Iaccino’s views or opinions expressed in the Content. TradeZero makes no representations or warranties with respect to the accuracy of the Content or information available through any referenced or linked third party sites. The Content has been made available for informational and educational purposes only and should not be considered trading or investment advice or a recommendation as to any security.

Trading securities can involve high risk and potential loss of funds. Furthermore, trading on margin is for experienced investors and traders only as the amount you may lose can be greater than your initial investment. Likewise, short selling as a securities trading strategy is extremely risky and can lead to potentially unlimited losses. Options trading is not suitable for all investors as it can involve risk that may expose investors to significant losses. Please read the Characteristics and Risks of Standardized Options, also known as the options disclosure document (ODD) at https://www.theocc.com/Company-Information/Documents-and-Archives/Options-Disclosure-Document before deciding to engage in options trading.

TradeZero provides self-directed brokerage accounts to customers through its operating affiliates: TradeZero America, Inc. a United States broker dealer, registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and member of the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) and the Securities Investor Protection Corporation(SIPC); TradeZero, Inc., a Bahamian broker dealer, registered with the Securities Commission of the Bahamas; and TradeZero Canada Securities ULC, a Canadian broker dealer, member firm of the Canadian Investment Regulatory Organization (CIRO) and member of the Canadian Investor Protection Fund (CIPF).